A multi-arm multi-stage clinical trial design for binary outcomes with application to tuberculosis
نویسندگان
چکیده
BACKGROUND Randomised controlled trials are becoming increasingly costly and time-consuming. In 2011, Royston and colleagues proposed a particular class of multi-arm multi-stage (MAMS) designs intended to speed up the evaluation of new treatments in phase II and III clinical trials. Their design, which controls the type I error rate and power for each pairwise comparison, discontinues randomisation to poorly performing arms at interim analyses if they fail to show a pre-specified level of benefit over the control arm. Arms in which randomisation is continued to the final stage of the trial are compared against the control on a definitive time-to-event outcome measure. To increase efficiency, interim comparisons can be made on an intermediate time-to-event outcome which is on the causal pathway to the definitive outcome. METHODS We adapt Royston's MAMS design to binary outcomes observed at the end of a fixed follow-up period and analysed using an absolute difference in proportions. We apply the design to tuberculosis (TB), an area where many new drugs are in development, and demonstrate how it can greatly accelerate the evaluation of new TB regimens. We use simulations to support the extensions to the methodology and to investigate the amount of bias in the estimated treatment effects of arms in which randomisation is ceased at the first interim analysis and arms which continue to the final stage of the trial. RESULTS The proposed seamless phase II/III TB trial designs are shown to greatly reduce sample size requirements and trial duration compared to conducting separate phase II and III trials. The bias in the estimated treatment effects for the definitive outcome is shown to be small, especially when treatment selection is based on an intermediate outcome or when a reanalysis is performed at the planned end of the trial after all recruited patients have completed follow-up. CONCLUSIONS The proposed designs are practical and could be used in a variety of disease areas. They hold considerable promise for speeding up the evaluation of new treatments particularly in TB where many new regimens will soon be available for testing in phase II and phase III trials.
منابع مشابه
A multi-arm multi-stage design for binary outcomes and application to tuberculosis
Multi-arm multi-stage (MAMS) designs can greatly increase the speed and efficiency of treatment evaluation compared to separate trials of each new therapy. A class of MAMS designs with stopping guidelines only for lack-of-benefit have been developed for time-to-event outcomes and have been used to design several trials in oncology. In these designs, interim assessments can be made on an interme...
متن کاملModifying the multi-arm multi-stage (MAMS) design for use in a phase II tuberculosis trial in sub-Saharan Africa with a time-to-event primary outcome
Background Tuberculosis (TB) causes significant morbidity and mortality globally. High efficacy in clinical trials of the current 4-drug 6-month regimen does not always translate into practice due to a heavy pill burden and long duration. New drugs are in late-phase clinical development, so trials that evaluate novel and existing drugs in combination are urgently needed. A multi-arm multi-stage...
متن کاملAdding Experimental Arms to Ongoing Clinical Trials
Multi-arm clinical trials use a single control arm to evaluate multiple experimental treatments. In most cases this feature makes multi-arm studies considerably more efficient than two-arm studies that evaluate single experimental treatments. A bottleneck for implementation is the requirement that experimental treatments need to be available at the enrollment of the first patient. New drugs are...
متن کاملThe R Package MAMS for Designing Multi-Arm Multi-Stage Clinical Trials
In the early stages of drug development there is often uncertainty about the most promising among a set of different treatments, different doses of the same treatment, or combinations of treatments. Multi-arm multi-stage (MAMS) clinical studies provide an efficient solution to determine which intervention is most promising. In this paper we discuss the R package MAMS that allows designing such ...
متن کاملAccelerating clinical development of HIV vaccine strategies: methodological challenges and considerations in constructing an optimised multi-arm phase I/II trial design
BACKGROUND Many candidate vaccine strategies against human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection are under study, but their clinical development is lengthy and iterative. To accelerate HIV vaccine development optimised trial designs are needed. We propose a randomised multi-arm phase I/II design for early stage development of several vaccine strategies, aiming at rapidly discarding those that ...
متن کامل